War of Religions
Five years later, the 16th-century theologian Martin Luther died. His words, printed and distributed widely, had catalysed the Reformation, which became the basis for the founding of Protestantism. The war of religions between Protestants and Catholics tore through much of Europe in the 16th and 17th centuries. In France, thousands of Protestants were murdered by Catholics in what became known as the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre of 1572.
In 1648, the Peace of Westphalia sought to end the religious war. It also provided the foundation of the concept of modern state sovereignty, with its principle “cuius regio, eius religio” (whose realm, his religion). This meant the people would follow the religion of whoever ruled the nation. In one fell swoop, almost all of northern Europe became Protestant–save for Ireland.
There are many reasons noted as to why Ireland remained stubbornly Catholic. One crucial reason was the growing tension between the Catholic Irish elite and the Protestant English monarchy. The Irish were being forced out of their lands in favour of the English, and they responded with rebellions during the reign of Elizabeth I. The rebellions were fought by the Irish lords to regain control of their lands and as a Roman Catholic crusade against the English queen.
The English crown instituted anti-Catholic penal laws in the early 17th century. These laws excluded Catholics from receiving education or from holding public office, and banned mixed marriages or Catholic inheritance of Protestant land. The Irish Catholic clergy and nobles, notably from the northern province of Ulster, left Ireland for Catholic countries in continental Europe, and their lands were taken over or sold to Protestant British people, ensuring that these regions were loyal to the crown.
By 1703, land owned by Catholics in Ireland were reduced to less than 15 percent.
The Great Irish Famine
In 1801, the Act of Union united Ireland to Great Britain (composed of England, Wales, and Scotland–read our previous article on the History of Wales).
The Act abolished the parliament in Dublin and moved it to the empire’s capital in Westminster, England, and the Church of Ireland was officially united with the Church of England.
The penal laws, still enforced at this time, relegated many Irish Catholics to work on farms they did not and could not own. The potato, introduced by the landed gentry, became the staple food of tenant farmers and the poor population. The farmers were living at subsistence level, barely producing enough crops for their own consumption and for their landowners, and the hardy potato was a dependable produce.
In 1845, Ireland’s potato crops began to rot in the fields, hit by blight caused by the water mould Phytophthora infestans. The crops failed in successive years and would not fully recover until 1852, leading to the Great Irish Famine, the worst famine to occur in Europe in the 19th century.
During this time, the British government did not put a stop to the export of Irish grain such as peas and beans to Great Britain, and even imported Indian corn or maize from the United States. Why then, while surrounded by this much food, did more than a million Irish men, women, and children still perish from starvation?
One reason was the British government’s laissez-faire approach–the crown believed there must be as little government interference with the economy as possible. This meant the export of grains to the rest of the kingdom must not be stopped, and spending public funds to feed a large population was unacceptable. (The British government did put up a soup kitchen, but only for six months.)
It also did not help that many British intellectuals believed the famine was caused by the Irish’s “moral defect”. As Jim Donnelly on the BBC says: “This amounted to a kind of racial or cultural stereotyping. The Irish had to be taught to stand on their own feet and to unlearn their dependence on government.”
Providing for the starving farmers was left in the hands of the landowners–again, a decision influenced by the laissez-faire, hands-off approach–but since the farmers could not pay their rent, the landowners ran out of funds to support them and ended up evicting the peasantry.
Those evicted were not given famine relief, and were instead sent to workhouses or employed on public works. The jobs did not pay enough for the workers to afford the price of food, which had skyrocketed due to the low supply and the price of importation.
The Great Famine drastically cut the Irish population, with many emigrating to other countries to escape poverty and hunger. By the early 1900s, Ireland’s population was half of what it had been before the famine.
It also deepened the Irish’s resentment of the British government, whose grudging and ultimately ineffective measures did not alleviate the nation’s suffering.
Irish War of Independence
The anti-Catholic penal laws and the results of the Great Famine would affect Ireland’s politics in the years to come. Many members of the Irish diaspora in Britain and the United States began the Fenian movement, named after a legendary group of Irish warriors (Fianna Eireann), to call for Ireland’s independence from Britain.
Ireland was soon split on the issue of home rule: Ireland should be a sovereign state, or it should remain with the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland with limited autonomy. The first proposition was advocated by the political party Sinn Féin (“We Ourselves”) and the radical Fenian organisation, the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB). The latter was supported by the Ulster Unionists.
War broke out in 1919 between the Irish Republican Army (whose leader was also president of the IRB) and the British forces supported by Ulster forces. In 1920, the Government of Ireland Act divided Ireland into two home-rule parliaments: the six counties in Ulster (Northern Ireland), and the 26 counties of the rest of Ireland (Southern Ireland).
The partition had a religious aspect: Ulster originally had nine counties but the unionists wanted a Protestant majority, so the majority-Catholic counties of Donegal, Cavan, and Monaghan were carved away from Ulster and lumped together with the rest of the nation.
The Act was rejected by the nationalists as it fell short of providing them full independence, and the guerrilla war continued.
In 1921, the Anglo-Irish Treaty was signed, and this formed what would become the sovereign Republic of Ireland, while Northern Ireland remained in the United Kingdom. The IRA split in two over the treaty–with one side supporting it and the other side still calling for complete Irish unity.
A civil war continued until 1923. The bloody war, which pitted former comrades of the IRA who just the year prior had fought side by side in the Irish War of Independence, ended with the defeat of the anti-treaty group.
“The Troubles”
The partition, in terms of sectarian lines, was not perfect. There were minority populations on both sides–Catholics in the north and Protestants in the south–that continued to face discrimination.
This uneven partition, among other complex factors, resulted in the explosion of violence in Northern Ireland in the late 1960s. “The Troubles” was a three-decade conflict between nationalists and unionists that led to bombings and street riots. It gave Belfast, the capital of Northern Ireland, the reputation as a dangerous city in the 1970s and 80s.
The conflict ended with the Good Friday Agreement of 1998, and Ireland, on both sides of the border, kept the peace and encouraged tourism on the island.
The Republic of Ireland is a member of the European Union, while Northern Ireland, as part of the United Kingdom, has voted to leave it. Only time will tell if “Brexit” will make this largely invisible border into a “hard border” once again.